As we mentioned a few weeks ago, there are many factors that go into the premium you pay for your insurance coverage: limits, extras, deductibles and more. This week, we are focusing on deductibles, and how those can impact your premium.
The deductible is the amount that you must pay out of pocket before an insurance company will pay for eligible expenses. There are three main types of deductibles: 1.) Dollar deductibles are a flat dollar amount ($500, $1,000, etc.); 2.) Percentage deductibles takes a percent of either the insurance amount, the value of the property, or the amount of the loss; 3.) Time deductibles determine an amount of time you must wait until payments can begin (this is most common for a business income coverage).
What does that mean for your deductible? Typically, the higher your deductible, the less the insurance company is responsible for, therefore the lower your premium is. There are some limitations in state law in terms of the maximum deductible allowed for each program, so it’s not an exact correlation in what your savings are. In other words, a certain auto program may be limited by the state to have a maximum 20% deductible savings. If you move from a $100 deductible to $250, it could save you 8%; from $250 to $500 could save another 8%, but then from $500 to $1,000, the savings would be capped at 4%, reaching the maxium 20%. So most companies spread the savings out across the deductible levels, making the change from one deductible to the next a varying savings percentage.
Several factors go into determining what your deductible should be. First, remember that deductibles are on a per claim basis. So if you have multiple claims in a policy period (6-months or 1-year), you would have to pay the deductible each time. Since we don’t plan to have one claim, let alone mulitiple claims, sometimes this is overlooked. It is also different with health insurance, where there are out of pocket maximums that can limit how much you would pay per year.
You should base your deductible on what could or would be comfortable or affordable for you in the event of a claim. If you are in an accident or have a loss at your home, can you really afford to pay the first $1,000 or $5,000 of a claim? Or would you be better to have a lower deductible?
Also, consider the value of what you are insuring, especially autos. If you have a car that is worth $1,500, a $1,000 deductible would make less sense, because if the vehicle were totalled, you would in essence only get $500. On the flip side, if you have a $30,000 car, and can afford a little more out of pocket in the event of a loss, it might make sense to save some on monthly premiums with a higher deductible.
There are some policy extras, too, that can offer you savings on your premium or deductible. These include a “vanishing deductible”—for a little extra premium, your deductible will decrease by a set amount (typically $100/year) for each year you don’t have a claim. So if your first year deductible is $500, and you go three years before a claim, the deductible would then be $200. Generally they will then go back to the $500 level and start the vanishing over after a set period of time.
Also, consider what your monthly or annual premiums might be. We understand that budgets are tight, and finding savings can be beneficial. But, don’t solely base your decision on what your monthly savings might be. Take time to consider the above information, too. That is why we recommend you work with an Indepdent Insurance Agent to determine your situation and help determine the best policy and coverages for you. We are able to work with multiple companies, and find the one that best suits your individual needs.
Each insurance policy is unique. While some generalities can be made, each situation should be reviewed on a case-by-case basis. This is not considered advice on any specific insurance matter. Please contact an agent to discuss any concerns you may have.